The case is before the supreme court because hain transferred the case to federal court anyway and persuaded the federal trial court that the lawsuit against whole foods (the texas company) was so feeble that the court should dismiss whole foods from the litigation. The high court’s dog food scuffle over federal versus state court jurisdiction has reemerged this term in a baby food brawl. However, upon review, the fifth circuit court of appeals reversed the lower court’s decision, reinstating whole foods in the lawsuit and thereby nullifying the trial court’s verdict that favored hain This reinstatement effectively invalidated federal jurisdiction, compelling the case’s return to state court. The couple bought the food, called earth’s best organic products, from whole foods market, the supermarket chain known for its natural and organic products, according to a lawsuit they later filed. Here, the fifth circuit's later conclusion that the district court should not have dismissed whole foods didn't retroactively make whole foods a party all along
And because the only parties to the final judgment were completely diverse, many of this court's cases, including caterpillar, instruct that
WATCH
